Mom’s $5 Million Lawsuit Targets ‘Toxic’ Frozen Pizzas Sold Locally

Katie Simpson notes trans fats and says pizzas have PHVO, a food additive banned worldwide.

Katie Simpson bought frozen pizzas about five times in the past year, including a California Pizza Kitchen Personal Pizza Barbeque Chicken and the same maker’s Crispy Thin Crust Pizza Signature Pepperoni.

But when she learned they contained trans fat—an ingredient linked to heart disease, diabetes and cancer—she felt as if she were sold poison.

That’s the argument being made in a $5 million federal class-action lawsuit that claims Nestle—makers of DiGiorno, Stouffer’s and California Pizza Kitchen frozen pizzas —is “placing profits over public health” by failing to remove trans fat.

The suit was filed in U.S. District Court in San Diego on behalf of Simpson, a mother of two young children. Her address isn’t given, but she lives in San Diego County.

“The most frequent of Ms. Simpson’s purchases of Nestle Trans Fat Pizzas were at the Target located at 2911 Jamacha Road” near Cuyamaca College in Rancho San Diego, said the suit [attached as a PDF].

The lawsuit says the frozen pizzas in question shouldn’t contain a toxic food additive banned all over the world, said Greg Weston, an attorney for the plaintiff.

California has banned trans fat in foods served in local restaurants,
but no bans on trans fat exist for packaged foods. The cities of New York
 and Philadelphia are among local governments that have enacted bans against trans fat in restaurant food.

Weston said the suit seeks all monies Nestle has ever made from frozen

In a statement, Nestle said it will vigorously defend itself against all “baseless allegations,’’ saying its pizza products are in strict compliance
with FDA and USDA regulations.

According to California Pizza Kitchen, the case applies only to frozen pizzas, not to restaurants bearing that name.

No hearing date has been set in the case, which has been assigned to 
U.S. District Judge Janis Sammartino. No jury trial has been demanded.

“Although there are safe, low-cost and commercially acceptable alternatives to trans fat, including those used in competing brands and even in a few Nestle and CPK products, defendants unfairly elect not to use those substitutes in the Nestle Trans Fat Pizzas in order to increase profit at the expense of consumer health,” says the 23-page suit.

The suit targets partially hydrogenated vegetable oil, or PHVO, which it says is the main source of trans fat in the American diet and “used in dangerous quantities in the Nestle Trans Fat Pizzas.”

PHVO, invented in 1901 and patented in 1902 by German chemist Wilhelm, was initially a “wonder product” attractive to the packaged food industry “because it combines the low cost of unsaturated … fat with the flexibility and long shelf life of saturated fat,” the suit says.

“Given its toxic properties, few food companies continue to use PHVO,” the suit says. “Defendants, however, have decided not to follow their more responsible peers and cease using PHVO, instead placing profits over public health and deliberately poisoning their consumers.”

The suit cites research that PHVO causes cardiovascular heart disease, diabetes, cancer, Alzheimer’s disease and accelerates cognitive decline in diabetics.

In 2008, California became the first state to ban all restaurant food with artificial trans fat, a law affecting about 88,000 eating establishments, the suit said.

“Trans fats now may not be served in California’s schools or restaurants in an amount greater than half a gram per serving,” the suit says.

—City News Service contributed to this report.

McNoodle January 31, 2013 at 11:58 PM
You know what a real poison is? Sodium Nitrite. I am sure it is in the Pepperoni or the Canadian Bacon or the sausage on the pizza she buys. BAD for your heart! There are nitrite free alternatives, so why doesn't she sue about that. She could sue nearly every pizza maker there (I hear the Red Baron has DEEP pockets!)
dank February 01, 2013 at 12:15 AM
Guys, obviously she is either dyslexic, blind or illiterate. The ingredients list needs to be made handicapped accessible. She deserves everything she has coming to her!
Batman February 01, 2013 at 03:32 AM
And formaldehyde pizza tastes better anyway.
Super Terrific Response February 01, 2013 at 06:40 AM
People will sue any entity for any reason it seems. What a joke. By the way, Kevin George, I think you meant "... the litigation must commence." Nevertheless, your sarcasm is appropriate in this case.
SDF February 01, 2013 at 07:13 AM
judge mental as two words? yep, that's your lowest common denominator in action...rofl, so retarded.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »